Wednesday, 26 August 2015

A Question of Orthopraxy

         Orthopraxy is defined as correct liturgical and ethical conduct. The question is, how does one define the word correct? As Fr. Richard Rohr says this week in his daily meditations, ".....we don't think our way into a new way of living; we live ourselves into a new way of thinking...." I think that anyone who has become involved in the Twelve Step Programme of spiritual recovery will vouch for the truth of that statement. As I have pointed out in earlier posts, the gift of belief in a power greater than our everyday consciousness, or ego, to save us from insane thinking and behaviour, is offered only after practical work on our psycho-spiritual condition. That work is not usually undertaken until we have experienced real, psychological suffering.
         I suppose we all know that if we wish to become adept at some skill or other, whether it be in some art activity, sport, or an intellectual activity, maybe learning a new language, for example, a great deal of work and commitment is usually required. It is tacitly assumed that the activity we choose has some positive value for us, and maybe our community as well. However, the goal of the aspiring adept may not be worthwhile. Thus the concentrated activity to acquire proficiency in a skill is not of itself laudable. It is the end to which our energies are engaged that may be deemed to be worthy or unworthy, sensible (sensical?) or nonsensical. Also, energy can be expended mistakenly so that bad habits and procedures are generated.
         In the early days of my spiritual turnaround, it was made quite clear to me which of my character traits were positive and constructive, and which were negative and destructive. The practising of the positive traits brought about a new and positive way of thinking, whilst the practising of negative traits had had the opposite effect. In a very real sense, negative behaviour has the effect of sending one into spiritual sleep, that condition that Gurdjieff so often warned against.
         One negative trait in particular (and not the only one!) that I needed to guard against was judgementalism. Trying to reach some understanding of the nature of this trait has occupied my attention, on and off, for a very long time. Of late, I have been reading excerpts from the New Testament because I wish to get to know (insofar as it is possible) this man Jesus of Nazareth, and what made him tick; what was he really trying to say? One thing that becomes very evident is his frequent verbal attacks on the 'Scribes and Pharisees' whom he labels as hypocrites. Now is that being judgemental or not? Similarly, wasn't St. Paul's calling the Galatians "stupid" also judgemental?
         In my book such outbursts are indeed examples of judgementalism. Yet it also displays behaviour that is all too human. Gone forever, in my mind, is the notion of Jesus the Nazarene as the epitome of divine perfection, being replaced by someone I can empathise with, someone who made all the mistakes that I make. Yet for all that, something lived its life through that mortal man, to telling effect; Jesus the Christ, the Jesus Higher Self, the Cosmic Christ.
         Of course, that does not mean that I can indulge in judgementalism with impunity. Gradually, I have come to believe that judgementalism is a negative activity directed at a person, not at their behaviour. I must surely become aware when I am engaged in a behaviour that is likely to damage my thinking process, that is going to turn my ways of thinking toward the realm of insanity, as they have done so in the past. Yet to say that I am this or that, rather than saying I am behaving like this or that, is as judgemental as if I am levelling my negative criticisms at others. Finally, after all these years I think I understand. And there is a bonus. If I can cease from being judgemental, I stand a chance of dealing with its accomplices, pride (arrogance) and self-righteousness. Now that can't be bad.

Saturday, 15 August 2015

Old Feelings Aroused

          Of late I have turned to reading the New Testament, admittedly in small chunks. In particular, I am reading some portions taken from St. Paul's letters to the peoples of various cities, such as those of Galatia to whom I referred in a previous post. The reasons for this are perhaps a little obscure, and need not detain us here. What intrigued me were the feelings that arose as I read his words.
          When I was a child and in the process of being educated about the love of God and the excruciating agony suffered by the Christ at Calvary - all for the benefit of saving my pretty worthless soul - I swallowed everything I was taught hook, line and sinker, as the saying goes. As a child Christian, the fishy metaphor is apt. What I could not see then, but can see all too clearly now, was the complete contradiction between what I was taught, and how it was taught to me, and what I trust is spiritual reality.
          To begin with (and let me say here at the outset that this is not a judgemental outburst against those who for all their supposed knowledge and wisdom really seemed to have lost the plot) the teaching of Christ's loving message was completely out of touch with the background of his vengeful Father, ever waiting to dole out punishment for all my little transgressions. Also, the way in which I was taught, so beloved of the Protestant low Church, was very much in the Pauline mode. Thus I developed a mindset that was overloaded with guilt, imminent divine punishment, coupled with a need that I abhorred of seeking to convert others to "my way" of thinking. (I never was very successful at doing that, and maintain my abhorrence at indulging in that practice even now.) Suddenly, my reading of St. Paul threw into high relief a kind of familiarity that was pressing all the wrong buttons.
          Perhaps that would have been a good time to dump my copy of the Holy Bible in the nearest bin, but I have always had a powerful aversion to destroying books. In any case, it was possible that I would have been throwing away the good with the bad. I have spent some days thinking over the feelings that have arisen, and the end result is a deep sadness. No real anger remains over my father's........oh hell, let him go!
          It is the sadness of apparent loss of something that may yet reveal something of deep value. I just don't know. It all seems to be so far too late! And when I look around the world, and frankly I am no lover of mankind, I nevertheless sense a deep regret at the huge loss that our species is suffering in the name of religious and political fundamentalism and egoistic arrogance, of arid intellectualism on the one hand and a swamping by an ocean of emotionalism on the other. Yet for all that is wrong, divisive, demanding and non-loving in this suffering world, I cannot deny that there is some intuitive good. For all the mistakes we make, there are some redemptive aspects to our behaviour. On such small and shaky foundations lies all the hope I can muster.
          A long time ago, I was told that I had barely scratched the surface of Christianity. Maybe, just maybe, the Christ said, and still says, something we - or at least this non-religious I - have a need to hear.

Sunday, 9 August 2015

Belief from Letting Go

          I observed in my previous post, "Belief As a Gift," that in order to arrive at a "right" answer, some kind of fearless, candid appraisal of appropriate data is required. Then one is placed in a position to experience the giving of belief. Why should this be so? After all, are we not able to acquire beliefs without undergoing the rigour of honest investigation? I would like, at this point, to distinguish between belief as I have been using that word, and something which one has acquired from someone else, a friend, a relative, a preacher speaking from a pulpit, a member of a peer group, or any other source of information - or disinformation(!) - which happens to suit one's prevailing predisposition.
          The latter kind of so-called belief is most likely to be gained in order to boost or titillate one's ego. In other words one's ego is enhanced by the acquisition of what is often an unhealthy dose of unreality. When belief is "gifted," however, a very different process is involved, namely a taking away from the ego. And this process, which is sometimes referred to as "letting go," is the crucial difference. Not only that, but letting go can be applied in a number of different situations, resulting in psycho-spiritual benefits for the receiver. It may well be this removal of substance - if I can call it that - from the stifling shell of the ego that brings about the receiving of the gift of belief that appears to have no connection with the subject being investigated.
          I wonder, having once experienced the process of, "Coming to believe....." why anyone would wish to return to the state of being totally dominated by one's ego. Perhaps this is what was in St. Paul's mind when he said in his "Letter to the Galatians" [3:ii and iii]:-

"How was it that you received the Spirit - was it by the practice of the Law, or by believing in the message you heard? Having begun in the Spirit, can you be so stupid as to end in the flesh?" [New Jerusalem Bible] A similar quote from the King James' Version says:-

"Are ye so foolish? Having begun in the Spirit, are ye now made perfect by the flesh (or ego)? Have ye suffered so many things in vain?......" [3:iii and iv]

          There is undoubtedly great power in the process of letting go. It almost demands a human response of faith. Of course this may fly in the face of the intellect, of rationality. That does not mean, however, that a faith response - a response from the heart - flies in the face of reality. But at all times discernment needs to be practised. Somewhere, somehow, doors are beginning to open; doors that for so long I have chosen to shut.

Thursday, 30 July 2015

Belief As a Gift

          What is the nature of belief? Of course one can get a definition of belief from the dictionary, but that is not what I am seeking. I am seeking something which seems to be indefinable. There appears to be no logical reason why one should hold this or that belief, although it does seem to me to require some intellectual, rational input to the search, if one hopes to arrive at a "right" answer. Without a fearless, candid appraisal of data supplied from one's experience there seems to be little chance of arriving at that answer whose origins lay in the realm of truth. However,  I must not stray too far into generalities about belief but move closer to something more specific.
          Over these last few weeks since my previous post, I have been assailed by thoughts, emotions and, in particular, moods that have caused me no little distress. I had reached a point of boredom with my inner work that had left me disappointed and frustrated. The causes of this state became clear enough when I realised my own ego was heavily involved. Yet I would not have wanted to avoid that descent into despair if it had meant that I would have lost a valuable lesson from the experience. Much of the experience of that descent I must leave for some possibly future post. At this moment I wish to concentrate on the experience of belief, noting that the word itself is unimportant, and may even be a hindrance to my understanding. Yet having said that, I immediately realise that I am not seeking any understanding, for that would be to indulge my ego once again.
          In the days of long ago when I first studied the "Twelve Step Programme", whilst recovering from the trauma of living with an alcoholic, there came a point when I "Came to believe......" Those three words are filled with a sense of wonder for me, not only because they were a part of a recovery journey but also because they hinted at a truth which only now am I beginning to see in a deeper sense. That experience followed an exhausting period during which I discovered, from an examination of my own experiences, just how powerless one is in the face of someone else's dysfunctional behaviour. And that was a good lesson to learn, not only for its own inherent value, but also because it now hints at a similarity with the experience of the quantum world. It may not be too big a jump to conclude that the principles that appear to rule quantum mechanics may also govern all human experience. However, to follow that train of thinking here would be to divert my attention from the purpose of this post.
          The experience of belief, particularly in the spiritual life, is not something that can be scrutinised too closely without it slipping out of awareness, only to return when attention is moved elsewhere. It's sheer uncertainty refuses one to pin it down. This conclusion obliges me to recognise that the gift of belief (and I do believe it to be a gift) comes from a realm of ultimate Reality, not from the closer realist world. And that implies that I do not generate my beliefs but accept them as inevitable consequences of right thought and inner actions, even possibly in an apparently non-related field, .
  In a somewhat roundabout way, and with a slight diversion into similarities with the realm of quantum thought, I am trying to get to grips with the idea that belief as something that I feel I own, as something self-generated, has in fact all the appearances of being something given to me from "elsewhere" which is pointing me towards mystical Truth, like a pointing finger which is not of itself Truth. Suddenly, belief and in particular belief in something divine, takes on a whole new dimension of wonder. I hold this precious gift in my hands, a gift which I must avoid egoistically owning as "mine", and try to accept it without grasping it; to observe it without focusing on it too deliberately; to meditate on it without resorting to mere words. I need to be prepared to lose this gift of belief so that I can remain in its presence.


Saturday, 9 May 2015

A Point of Despair

          Haiku; the particular implying the general. It seems that the acorn implies the oak tree, because the acorn has all the potential within it to create an oak tree. But that is not the end of the story, because the acorn could not exist without a prior oak tree, and it could not grow without a supportive medium in which its needs are met. If the oak is the macro to the micro implied by the acorn, to what is the acorn an equivalent macro? The oak tree's DNA perhaps that is present within the tree and the seed. But of what is DNA constructed? How many steps are implied by any manifestation of creation?
          I, like many others I suspect, are accustomed to talking about the Higher and the lower selves. The lower self seems to be small in comparison with the Higher Self, unless the lower self or ego is viewed solely against the psycho/material background of consciousness. Yet I am aware of an inner observing role with which I become involved, which is neither 'lower' nor 'Higher'. It is that same observing function that becomes involved in the Great Work of becoming aware of my ego and all its traits: it is that same observing function that becomes aware of far more than psycho/materiality. That observing Self can be involved in both activity and observation, yet it is neither the doer nor the observer. It is that which lies behind both functions. It is analogous to the One who was reportedly involved in the creation of the universe, as well as observing 'that it was good' on the seventh day.
          From this particular perspective, I see that the lower self does not exist independently but as part of a system of possibilities. As with Alistair Crowley, it seems to me that the Higher Self also does not have an independent existence either, because it is inextricably linked to a non-independent entity called the ego. There is only "I", and I am that I am. Everywhere I 'look' I see only possibilities for change that can be, to a greater or lesser extent, effective and efficient. In that context, morality becomes a system of guidelines towards greater efficiency without any overtones of judgementalism.
          Somewhere within, what for the want of a better word I will call the Self, lies a very great deal of unconscious information. Growing experience makes conscious an increasing number of examples of both efficient and inefficient ways of being. But how much experience do I need to acquire? Is it enough to see that in all important effects, I - that is the Self - is a copy (at the very least) of the One? I create within myself the totality of the universe that I can sense, and I can also observe and draw the conclusion 'It is that It is.' Is it possible that I can conclude that I am now at a stepping-off point into a greater inner universe? Or should I conclude that the universe now inevitably falls in on itself on the one hand, or expands to a state of virtual nothingness, at an ever-increasing rate, on the other hand? Either way, isn't the universe ultimately a pointless exercise in acorn production?

Saturday, 2 May 2015

Unblocking the Pathways

          In a recent pathworking, in which I entered the secret garden and attempted to take a shower in the gazebo (the details of this pathworking are not important here), I discovered that I would not come clean. The problem of being covered in something unclean, whether in the material world or the world of the spirit, is that more of the same tends to attach itself to that skin of impurity. This is particularly true when one is dealing with psycho-spiritual denial. One could say that one acquires 'attachments.' Meister Eckhart once said,

"The more God is in all things, the more He is outside them. The more He is within, the more without."

          It is taught that God is both totally transcendent and totally immanent. If I could skirt around the God word here, it is not unreasonable to say that if I am genuinely to enter into the necessary process of "knowing oneself", then I need to take on the mantle of divinity, in other words to reach out far beyond what has been called the higher Self. Only then can I enter the realm of the ego, and truly know it, without becoming in any way attached to it, thus freeing myself from its dominion. When I talk about the ego here, I am referring not only to my conscious personality; its traits negative and positive; its thoughts, emotions and senses, but also to its natural tendency to form attachments. Thus, if I am 'unclean' I do not know myself; if I cannot come clean, I can never know myself.
          To achieve the ultimate state of spiritual cleanliness, or to become totally transcendent, does not seem to me to require a single, giant step. The work that needs to be done is a process of step-taking, each step raising myself to ever 'higher' levels. The higher I am able to go, the more deeply I can immerse myself in the process of "knowing myself" without risking attachment. The more transcendent the Self becomes, the more immanent it becomes. It may well follow that the more I know my lower self, and unblock the inner, lower pathways, the more I can consciously experience my higher Self.  

Saturday, 25 April 2015

Systems Analysis - Of a Kind

          The purpose of this pathworking was not to determine whether there was a problem to be addressed, but what the nature of that problem was. In combination with this meditation I carried out a series of contemplations - never easy for me - to elucidate further the nature of my problem.

..........After a while, I once more approached the garden, knocked, and entered. The Gardener walked beside me as once again I walked the familiar path away from the gazebo. I noted that there was something alien about the Gardener but this caused me no concern at all. I approached the point where the Nail was driven into the path, the Nail from which I had seemingly been released. Such symbols will arise from time to time, just like other memories or quotations perhaps, but they must not assume undue importance, dragging me towards a study of symbolic systems. They are not truth, only possible pointers to truth.
          A little further along the path, maybe a step or two, I saw that the pathway was flooded with water. In each flower bed on either side of the path was a small pool. However, the water which was designed to flow down from the left-hand pool to the right-hand pool by means of an underground conduit, was seeping across the path. The conduit appeared to be blocked. I also saw a cleared channel cutting across the path, as if that is how the connection between the pools should or must appear. The channel is invisible under normal conditions just as the Nail is invisible and had [has] to loose the tie that binds my ankle. Thus there seems to be a link between the blocked conduit and the tie to the Nail..........

          Finally, I am beginning to feel what is wrong, or at least what appears to be wrong. To begin with, the 'feel' of my surroundings is different; the Gardener is now somewhat alien, that is different from my normal apprehension of him. The future course of events must take me into stranger realms than I have yet visited. The presence of the Lion, not noted in this current pathworking description, is an indicator of my need for great strength of will, or courage, if I am to clear the blockage and move onwards.
          It was through my contemplative exercises that I began to see that I often take recourse to safe measures that are not taking me where I need to go. Over the years, as I have said elsewhere, I have studied "The Twelve Steps", some Transpersonal Psychology, the Mystical Qabalah as well as some studies into Christianity. All this has been backed by the reading of what others have said in their writings about the psycho-spiritual life, and how their experiences have gelled with mine. And there is a great deal of safety in remaining 'in orbit', so to speak, about the wisdom, knowledge and understanding expressed by others. In other words I need to break free of the 'systems' as laid down by others. That work was all about their experiences, interpreted in ways which they felt led to do. Those experiences were not, and can never be, mine. How beguiling it would be to act the part of a sheep, and follow the shepherd.
          Now it would be foolishness and hubris to discount what others have said, and that is not the way I intend to go. I have gained much from my studies, but they must be used only as stepping stones towards a greater goal, and one of which I am only now beginning to glimpse. To be candid, the thought of breaking free from my past is not one that rests easily and comfortably with me. Where once I might have attacked, now I must persuade; where once I might have used my spiritual weight to barge through obstacles, now I must tread delicately. The risk of pridefulness, and the consequent making of mistakes, is very real. Yet I cannot avoid the conclusion that useful though my past has been, it is no longer enough. There needs to be, yes a breakout, but also a refining of method and approach. The tools that have been used to good effect, must now be modified to deal with a subtler form of experience.
          I may not succeed, but if I refuse to knock, the door will never be opened to me. If I refuse to seek, I will never find. Yet 'success' is not really part of this enterprise. It never has been. That is mere ego-speak. The concept of success is meaningless, and that I must always bear in mind. I must remove my spiritual shoes which block my sense of the holy, and walk barefoot.